Yokohama tires are more suited for an all-season grip, whether you are driving in summer or winter. Whereas, Pirelli shows superior performance in grip and durability for off-road driving. Both Yokohama and Pirelli tires show excellent performance and comfort for your car but when it comes to fuel economy, Pirelli tires have the better performance.
With that clarified, it is important to know the factors that have been defined to compare between Yokohama and Pirelli tires. This is exactly what the next steps deal with along with mention of some relevant and important tire models. So let’s get into the discussion right away.
Yokohama VS Pirelli Tires: Sports Car Comparison
Let’s begin by comparing the sports car tire between Yokohama tires and Pirelli tires. Here, the comparison is made between Yokohama Advan Sport v105 VS Pirelli P Zero. The table below shows some of the key factors that will show the difference between Yokohama and Pirelli.
| Factors | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| Dry Traction | Better Dry Traction | Good Dry Traction |
| Wet Traction | Good Wet Traction | Good Dry Traction |
| Tire Wearing Resistance | Better Tire Wearing Resistance | Good Tire Wearing Resistance |
| Tread Life Warranty | 55,000 miles or 60 months from the date of purchase to 72 months from the date of manufacture | 50,000 miles |
| Fuel Economy | Good Fuel Economy | Good Fuel Economy |
| Notable Tire Family | Advan, Avid, Tornante, YK, BlueEarth | P Zero [For Cars]Scorpion Zero [For SUVS] |
| Cost | $100 – $1400 | $145 – $1200 |
So, the table shows that the result between Yokohama and Pirelli tires is pretty even. There is not much difference and you are good to go with either of these options. But let’s get into the details to know the reason for this even performance.
Dry Traction
Yokohama Advan Sport v105 contains Microsilica and Orange Oil enhanced tread compounds that help to make the tread rubber more pliable. The advantage here is better grip and contact with dry road surface
Pirelli tires also come with impressive grip on dry surfaces. It is made with silica enhanced tread compound along with the asymmetric tread design that ensures better footprint rigidity to have dry traction.
But due to the inclusion of the latest technology such as using Orange Oil, Yokohama Advan Sport v105 tires have better dry traction for performance tires.
Verdict:
Choose Yokohama Advan Sport v105 tires instead of Pirelli P Zero for better performance in dry traction.
Wet Traction
Yokohama tires are good at hydroplaning resistance thanks to the circumferential grooves that help to expel out water. Moreover, the shoulder blocks and circumferential ribs also help to maintain grip on slippery surfaces.
Pirelli tires are also good at hydroplaning resistance since most of its tires come with an asymmetric design that has circumferential and lateral grooves minimizing the formation of water beneath the tire.
Now, in a general sense, there isn’t a major difference in which one is better between the Pirelli P Zero and Yokohama Advan Sport v105.
Verdict:
Both Pirelli and Yokohama tires are good choices for wet traction performance comparison.
Tire Wearing Resistance
Yokohama tires will not disappoint you when it comes to durability. The tires are made with rigid steel belts in its internal structure. Along with this, it has the Matrix Body Ply structure technology that helps the sidewall to maintain lateral rigidity. This technology also helps in better handling and a comfortable ride.
Pirelli P Zero tires also have good tire wearing resistance. Its tire internal structure comes with different options with the initial twin steel belts and nylon combination. The tire is made with special nano composite in its tread compound that help it from detoriation. Along with that it has a strong internal structure with its twin steel belts reinforced by polyamide cord plies. .
But due to the presence of special nano composites in the tread compound, Pirelli P Zero has better durability.
Verdict:
If you are looking for a tire with better tire durability then choose Pirelli P Zero.
Fuel Economy
The fuel economy of the tire depends on the tire rolling resistance. Tire rolling resistance in simple words is how much effort the tire has to give to roll. More effort means more fuel consumption rate.
Large fuel consumption rate means worse fuel economy. Rolling resistance is affected by tire tread depth. The deeper tread depth means less material on tire tread and it will take more effort to roll the tires
So, the table below shows the tread depth for 32nds of an inch in both Yokohama and Pirelli tires at different tire parameters.
| Tire Parameters | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| 245/40ZR19 | 10/32 of an inch | 9/32 of an inch |
| 245/35ZR20 | 10/32 of an inch | 10/32 of an inch |
The table clearly shows that there is no major difference in the tread depth between Yokohama and Pirelli tires. For some tire models you will have deeper tread depth for Yokohama tires while for other Pirelli will have it deeper. In some cases, the tread depth will be even.
This shows that fuel economy is going to be almost the same for both Yokohama and Pirelli tires.
Verdict:
You will get almost similar levels of fuel economy from both Yokohama and Pirelli tires.
Yokohama VS Pirelli Tires: On-Road Comparison
Now let’s drive into the comparison between the on-road tire options. We do the detailed comparison between Yokohama Avid Ascend GT VS Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season. The following table shows the difference in the performance from Yokohama and Pirelli.
| Factors | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| Dry Traction | Good Dry Traction | Better Dry Traction |
| Wet Traction | Good Wet Traction | Better Wet Traction |
| Noise | Good Noise Resistance | Good Noise Resistance |
| Tire Wearing Resistance | Good Tire Wearing Resistance | Good Tire Wearing Resistance |
| Tread Life Warranty | 70,000 – 85,000 miles | 50,000 – 70,000 miles |
| Fuel Economy | Good Fuel Economy | Better Fuel Economy |
| Notable Tire Family | Avid, Tornante | Cinturato, Scorpion |
| Cost | $95 – $200 | $110 – $260 |
So from the table you can see that in most factors Yokohama tires seem to dominate. Let’s go through the details on why that is the case.
Dry Traction
Yokohama Avid Ascend GT tires are made with asymmetric tread pattern and engineered specially to have maximum contact patch with the road surface to have more traction. A common rule is that more contact patch with the road means there will be more traction.
Pirelli tires are also made with advanced polymer materials to ensure good contact patch and therefore grip on the dry road surface. On top of that, there is also a robust outboard shoulder that helps to improve the tire traction. Due to better contact surface with the road, Pirelli Cinturato P7 All season has better dry traction.
Verdict:
Go for Pirelli Cinturato P7 All season over Yokohama Avid Ascend GT for better dry traction.
Wet Traction
A tire with good wet traction ability means being resistant to hydroplaning. Hydroplaning is the eventual formation of water beneath the tire surface that creates slip in the movement. Your tire’s hydroplaning resistance will depend on how good the grooves are designed.
For Yokohama tires, the grooves are deep, wide and circumferential and the inside shoulder contains open notches, the combination of which enables easy flow of water so it doesn’t accumulate beneath the tire and allows tire movement.
On top of that it also has technology such as the TriBLEND compound technology that uses the combination of low-Tg polymer and high silica content for ensuring traction on slippery surfaces.
Pirelli tires are also a good option for hydroplaning resistance because of its circumferential and wide grooves that helps to expel excess water. But when it comes to overall comparison, thanks to multiple sipes and biting edges, Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season will have better grip on wet surface in comparison to Yokohama Avid Ascend tires.
Verdict:
Go for Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season over Yokohama Avid Ascend for better performance on wet traction.
Noise
On Yokohama AVID Ascent GT you get the duo of pitch variation and adaptive shoulder blocks that help for a quieter ride. Either way, Yokohama tires are a good choice if you want a quieter ride.
The asymmetric tread pattern of Pirelli tires along with the shoulder blocks make it able to have relatively quieter rides with Pirelli. But with recent focus on Green Performance, Pirelli has focused on maintaining a quieter, more comfortable and environment friendly ride.
Verdict:
Both Yokohama and Pirelli tires will give you a quieter ride.
Tire Wearing Resistance
Yokohama tires are generally made with a unique polymer blend compound that helps to increase the durability of the tires and also maintain uniform pressure distribution through the wider and flatter tread contour that eventually protects tires from wearing out.
Pirelli tires have good durability thanks to its internal structure that uses twin steel belts along nylon cap ply. But beyond that, it uses technologies such as the Pirelli Seal Inside technology that uses adhesive sealant to make the tires more resistant against punctures and blowouts. The use of this sealant makes Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season the more durable option between the two.
Verdict:
Choose Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season over Yokohama Avid Ascend for better tire wearing resistance.
Fuel Economy
Yokohama tires are made with a focus on reducing the rolling resistance to improve its fuel economy. Especially if you consider its BluEarth tire family, it is made with environmental sustainability as the main priority where it uses orange oil instead of petroleum.
Now with that cleared out, let’s compare the tread depth for 32nds of an inch between Yokohama and Pirelli tires to see how the rolling resistance is going to be.
| Tire Parameters | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| 235/45R18 | 12/32 of an inch | 10/32 of an inch |
| 225/45R17 | 12/32 of an inch | 10/32 of an inch |
From the table it can be seen that Yokohama tires have deeper tread depth, this means it will have higher rolling resistance compared to Pirelli tires. This means Pirelli Cinturato P7 All season tires are better suited for fuel economy.
Verdict:
Choose Pirelli Cinturato P7 All Season tires instead of Yokohama Avid Ascend tires if your main priority is fuel economy.
Yokohama VS Pirelli Tires: Off Road Comparison
When it comes to off-road tires in both all-terrain and mud-terrain categories, both Yokohama and Pirelli tires have an impressive collection. We compare the performance between Yokohama Geolander-AT G015 and Pirelli Scorpion ATR. The table below shows the comparison between Yokohama and Pirelli.
| Factors | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| Dry Traction | Good Dry Traction | Better Dry Traction |
| Wet Traction | Good Wet Traction | Better Wet Traction |
| Tire Wearing Resistance | Good Tire Wearing Resistance | Good Tire Wearing Resistance |
| Notable Tire Family | Geolandar | Scorpion |
| Cost | $120 – $720 | $180 – $550 |
From the table above it shows that despite having lower options in the product list through individual comparison Pirelli tires seem to perform better. But with Yokohama tires you get a diversity of options that shows excellent performance. Now, let’s get right into the details of comparison between Yokohama and Pirelli tires.
Dry Traction
Yokohama tires are made with triply polymer compound incorporated with an aggressive tread design that lets good grip on dry surfaces. The advantage of using Triple polymer blend compound is its cut and chip resistance that makes it good for grip.
Pirelli tires are made with silica based tread compound that helps to maintain good grip. On top of that, it comes with deep grooves and independent tread blocks to help in having proper traction on loose surfaces.
Verdict:
Pirelli tires show better dry traction performance in comparison to Yokohama tires.
Wet Traction
In terms of hydroplaning resistance, you will get optimal performance from Yokohama tires due to its use of combination grooves that have a mix of sipes and narrow grooves. Moreover it uses siping along with the polymer blend compound mentioned earlier to have good traction for wet surfaces.
Wet traction ability of Pirelli tires is good thanks to its wide circumferential grooves and the lateral notches both helping in the flow of water to maintain good hydroplaning resistance. On top of that there are also multiple block edges and in-block sipes to help with the grip.
Verdict:
Go for Pirelli tires if you want to have optimal performance from wet traction.
Tire Wearing Resistance
You get the maximum comfort and tire wear resistance from Yokohama tires due to its internal construction that uses steel belts along with nylon wrapped around it. Geolandar X-AT uses the Geo-Shield construction where three instead of two ply are used which provides additional strength and durability to the tires.
Pirelli tires have internal construction that along with the polyester cord ensures a promising ride with good durability. It comes with two steel belts that elevates the comfortness and the longevity of the tires.
Verdict:
Both Pirelli and Yokohama tires will come with the best option for tire wearing resistance. You can choose any one of them.
Yokohama VS Pirelli Tires: Winter Tire Comparison
Finally, it’s time to compare the winter tires between Yokohama and Pirelli. The detailed comparison will be between Yokohama BluEarth v905 VS Pirelli Sottozero 3. The table below shows the table of comparison.
| Factors | Yokohama | Pirelli |
| Snow Grip | Better Snow Grip | Good Snow Grip |
| Tire Wear Resistance | Good Tire Wear Resistance | Good Tire Wear Resistance |
| Handling | Good Handling | Better Handling |
| Noise & Comfort | Quiet and Comfortable Ride | Quieter and More Comfortable Ride |
| Notable Tire Family | iceGuard, Bluearth | Sottozero, Cinturato, Scorpion, Carrier |
| Cost | $125 – $200 | $200 – $460 |
Snow Grip
Yokohama BluEarth Winter v905 is made with a high silica compound that has the Orange Oil technology incorporated in it. This makes the tire remain flexible enough and provide good grip across different temperature ranges. Moreover, its directional tread pattern along with the wide grooves allow for evacuating away water and snow and maintain good hydroplaning resistance.
Pirelli Sottozero 3 uses special polymers that improve the tread rubber compound and enhance the contact patch over the surface. Along with this, the rounded shoulder along with arrow shaped center blocks help to evacuate away water.
But due to using technology like the Orange Oil, Yokohama BluEarth v905 is the better option.
Verdict:
Choose Yokohama BluEarth v905 for better snow grip.
Tire Wear Resistance
Yokohama tires have the internal construction of two ply polyester casing that maintains the durability of the tire. Along with that it has the snow platform indicator molded into it which shows the tread depth remaining in the tire.
Pirelli tires are constructed in a manner to evenly distribute the pressure throughout the tire. This not only ensures good grip but also better durability from Pirelli tires.
Verdict:
For tire wear resistance, you can choose any of the options between Pirelli and Yokohama tires.
Handling
Yokohama tire’s internal construction and the biting edges ensures that the tires have good contact with the road surface and therefore better handling. Other than that, the nylon reinforcement ply also helps to get the required handling.
You get optimal stability from Pirelli tires thanks to the cap and base tread compound technologies which use two different compounds to come in contact with the road surface. But it is the high density 3D Sipe technology that improves the braking performance of the tire and enhances snow to snow traction.
Verdict:
Go for Pirelli Sottozero 3 tires for optimal performance in winter tire handling.
FAQs
Is Yokohama Advan Sport Any Good For My C63 AMG?
Yes, Yokohama Advan Sport is a good choice for your Mercedes-AMG C63. Thanks to its tread pattern that allows for good grip on the road and efficient cornering stability you can get the best performance from Advan Sport. Beyond that, it also comes with good tread wear resistance making it more durable.
Is Pirelli Scorpion Good For Snow?
Yes, Pirelli Scorpion Winter is a good option for snow. It comes with a tread design that ensures good grip on both the dry and snowy conditions. Beyond that, its tread profile enables it to have proper handling and steering response. So, if you are looking to buy a winter tire with optimal traction, hill braking and cornering then go for Pirelli Scorpion Winter.
Can I Replace Scorpion MTR With Yokohama Geolandar A/TG015?
Yes, you can replace Scorpion MTR with Yokohama Geolandar A/TG015. Since both of the options are off-road tires primarily made for all-terrain purposes. This means you will get optimal performance for both on-road and off-road conditions.
Conclusion
With that you should be able to select the best option between Yokohama VS Pirelli tires. Always remember to keep in mind the relevant factors for you and the cost of Yokohama and Pirelli tires.
Additionally, you should take it one step further by comparing two specific tire models from Yokohama and Pirelli based on the suggestion I gave here for the final decision.
